"When Lights Are Low" was composed by Benny Carter in 1936, with lyrics by Spencer Williams. Carter was a remarkably versatile musician—an alto saxophonist, trumpeter, arranger, and bandleader whose career spanned over six decades and helped shape the course of jazz from the swing era through the modern period.
The tune is a 32-bar AABA form in Eb major. The A sections feature a smooth, singable melody that epitomizes Carter's elegant swing style. The real harmonic adventure lies in the bridge, which passes through four different key centers in just eight bars—an extraordinarily bold move for 1936 that anticipated the chromatic sophistication of bebop by more than a decade. This contrast between the lyrical A sections and the harmonically adventurous bridge gives the tune a depth that rewards repeated listening and improvisation.
Carter's first recording was made in London in June 1936 with his Swing Quartet, featuring vocalist Elisabeth Welch. The song was subsequently covered by Lionel Hampton, whose vibrant vibraphone treatments helped popularize it, and Sarah Vaughan and Tony Bennett both recorded memorable vocal versions.
The Real Book (6th Edition)
The ultimate jazz fake book. A must-have for all gigging musicians.
Check on Amazon.com